When the college football season kicked off this year USC and LSU stood at number one and two in the polls respectively. This began the feud that has been talked about so often this season. Which conference is better? The Pac-10 or the SEC?
Well, as we finish up week seven of the season, both USC and LSU have fallen from the ranks of the undefeated, and all but crushed our hopes of deciding this argument on the field. So I am going to have to do the dirty work and look into these two powerhouse conferences to decide which one is the best based on the polls, depth of the conference, and finally head-to-head match-ups to decide which conference comes out on top.
Polls. In the most recent AP poll the SEC currently has seven teams in the top twenty-five compared to the Pac-10’s four, but we can’t give the point to the SEC just based on that. Yes, the SEC does have three more teams in the top 25, but four of those teams have already suffered two losses on the season. Florida, Auburn, Tennessee and Georgia have all struggled in the early goings.
When you look at the Pac-10 you find three teams with one loss (USC, Oregon and California) and the undefeated Arizona State Sun Devils. This gives the Pac-10 four possible contenders for the National Title to the SEC’s three.
Edge: Pac-10
Depth. As you look at the bottom of the barrel in the SEC you find many teams that can still give the frontrunners of the division a scare.
At the bottom of the SEC East you find Vanderbilt. They are 3-3 overall, and 1-3 in the conference, but they gave Georgia a run for their money this Saturday, and will not lie down against the remainder of their SEC East schedule. Teams like this are scattered throughout the SEC. Ole Miss, Arkansas and Mississippi State are all bottom dwellers in the SEC West, but have and will give every team in the SEC a good game.
When you go look at the Pac-10 you can’t come to the same conclusion. Stanford, Arizona, Washington and Washington State round out the bottom of the division this year and you could expect to look this time next year and find the same four teams. Yes, Stanford took down the number one USC Trojans, but would you bet on them to beat UCLA or even Washington? I think not.
The SEC takes this one in a blowout.
Edge: SEC
For the final round, I will give you the best match-ups and tell you who I think would come out on top.
1. LSU vs. Southern California
2. USC vs. Arizona State
3. Kentucky vs. UCLA
4. Florida vs. California
5. Auburn vs. Oregon
6. Alabama vs. Oregon State
7. Tennessee vs. Stanford
8. Georgia vs. Arizona
9. Mississippi State vs. Washington
10. Arkansas vs. Washington State
So I see it coming out as an 8-2 victory in favor of the SEC. You can look at those games and point to a few that could swing either way, but not enough to give the Pac-10 an edge. The major difference is in the final five match-ups. In my eyes, each one of those games would be dominated by the SEC team.
Point and match goes to the SEC.
If only these two conferences did not play their games on polar opposites of the United States we would be to solve this debate on the field, but for now, pen and paper is the best we can do.
Ed Cahill
Sports Blogger